[toc]
quoting accurately guidelines best practices
Concise Guide to APA Style: 7th Edition (OFFICIAL)
Page 222 Review
The Importance of Accuracy and Context in Quotations: A Deep Dive
Quoting material accurately and providing the necessary context is crucial in academic and scholarly writing.
Failing to do so can lead to misinterpretations and a weakening of your argument.
This essay delves into the nuances of direct quotations, drawing primarily from established guidelines on the subject.
It explores the critical aspects of accuracy, necessary changes, and appropriate referencing, ensuring that readers can effectively utilize quotations in their work.
Accuracy in Direct Quotations
One of the cardinal rules of using quotations is maintaining accuracy.
As stated, “Direct quotations must be accurate.
Except as noted here and in Sections 8.30 and 8.31, the quotation must match the wording, spelling, and interior punctuation of the original source, even if the source is incorrect.” This principle emphasizes the importance of meticulous transcription.
Even minor deviations from the original text can alter the meaning or introduce unintended errors.
The guidelines further address how to handle errors found within the source material. “If any incorrect spelling, punctuation, or grammar in the source might confuse readers, insert the word ‘[sic],’ italicized and in brackets, immediately after the error in the quotation.” This annotation serves to inform the reader that the error is not a mistake on the part of the quoter but exists in the original source.
It maintains transparency and prevents any misattribution of the error to the current writer.
For example, the following illustrates how to acknowledge an error in the source: “Nowak (2019) wrote that ‘people have an obligation to care for there [sic] pets’ (p. 52).” The inclusion of ‘[sic]’ clarifies that the misspelling of ‘their’ as ‘there’ is present in Nowak’s original text.
However, it’s also advised that “A quotation that includes an error may be distracting, so consider paraphrasing instead.” While it’s essential to represent the source accurately, clarity should take precedence.
If an error-laden quotation detracts from the overall message, paraphrasing the idea while citing the source might be a better approach.
Acceptable Changes to Quotations
While accuracy is paramount, certain changes to quotations are permissible without needing explicit notification.
According to the guidelines, “Some changes can be made to direct quotations without alerting readers.” These alterations usually involve adapting the quotation to fit grammatically and syntactically within the new context.
One acceptable change is adjusting the capitalization of the first letter. “The first letter of the first word in a quotation may be changed to an uppercase or a lowercase letter to fit the context of the sentence in which the quotation appears.” This allows writers to seamlessly integrate quotations into their sentences, ensuring grammatical correctness.
For instance, if a quotation begins mid-sentence in the original source, its first letter can be capitalized if it starts a new sentence in the current work.
Referencing Canonicallly Numbered Sections
The handling of quotations also varies based on the type of source material.
When dealing with works that have canonically numbered sections, such as religious texts or classical literature, specific referencing conventions apply. “To directly quote from material with canonically numbered sections (e.g., religious or classical works; see also Section 9.41 and Chapter 10, Examples 35-37), use the name of the book, chapter, verse, line, and/or canto instead of a page number.” This method ensures that readers can easily locate the quoted material within the original text, irrespective of different editions or versions.
An example of referencing such a work is: “The person vowed to ‘set me as a seal upon thine heart’ (King James Bible, 1769/2017, Song of Solomon 8:6).” Here, the reference includes the text, version of the bible, and specific verse.
Similarly, for plays, referencing should indicate the act, scene, and line numbers. “For plays, cite the act, scene, and line(s).
In the following example, ‘1.3.36-37’ refers to Act 1, Scene 3, Lines 36 and 37.” For instance, “In Much Ado About Nothing, Don John said, ‘In the meantime / let me be that | am and seek not to alter me’ (Shakespeare, 1623/1995, 1.3.36-37).” This specific citation enables readers to find the exact location of the quote within the play.
Additional Guidance
It is important to refer to additional information for citing specific parts of a source. “See Section 8.13 for further guidance on citing specific parts of a source (e.g., chapters, paragraphs, sections, tables, and figures of articles, books, and reports; time stamps in videos or audiobooks; slide numbers of PowerPoint presentations; canonically numbered parts of religious and classical works).” This section provides comprehensive guidelines for a wide range of source types and their specific citation needs.
Conclusion
In conclusion, accuracy in quotations is not merely a formality but a fundamental aspect of academic integrity.
The guidelines outlined emphasize the need for meticulous transcription, appropriate acknowledgment of errors, and accurate referencing.
By adhering to these principles, writers can ensure that their use of quotations enhances the clarity, credibility, and overall quality of their work.
Buy full ebook for only $18: https://www.lulu.com/shop/american-psychological-association/concise-guide-to-apa-style-7th-edition-official/ebook/product-rmzpq54.html?page=1&pageSize=4