Sunrise on the Reaping (A Hunger Games Novel) (The Hunger Games)
Page 24 Review
The Inevitability of Change: A Commentary on Perspective
In this poignant excerpt, we witness a clash of perspectives between two characters grappling with the established order. The conversation revolves around the inevitability of the ‘reaping,’ a grim tradition deeply ingrained in their society. The dialogue highlights the human tendency to accept the status quo, while also subtly challenging the notion that the future must mirror the past.
The conversation begins with the narrator’s simple observation: “Is it? I say. Because it’s kind of how people plan out their lives.” This statement reveals a sense of acceptance, a passive acknowledgement that the ‘reaping’ is a constant, an unchangeable element around which life is structured.
Challenging the Inevitable
However, this viewpoint is immediately challenged by the other character, Lenore Dove, who asserts: “And that’s part of our trouble. Thinking things are inevitable. Not believing change is possible.” Lenore’s words strike at the heart of complacency. She identifies the belief in inevitability as a fundamental problem, a barrier to progress and hope. She advocates for a mindset that embraces the possibility of change.
The narrator counters with a common, perhaps naive, sentiment: “I guess. But I can’t really imagine the sun not rising tomorrow.” This analogy highlights the difficulty in envisioning a world without the familiar. Just as the sunrise is a daily certainty, the ‘reaping’ has become an ingrained reality in their lives.
The Logic of Questioning Traditions
Lenore responds with a powerful hypothetical question: “Can you imagine it rising on a world without a reaping?” This question forces the narrator, and the reader, to confront the possibility of a different reality. It prompts a re-evaluation of the ‘reaping’ and its place in their world.
The narrator’s initial resistance is evident: “Not on my birthday. I’ve never had one that came without a reaping.” Here, the personal connection to the event further solidifies its perceived inevitability. The ‘reaping’ is not just a tradition, but a personal experience, inextricably linked to a significant date.
Lenore persists, determined to break through the narrator’s ingrained beliefs: “No, listen,” she says earnestly. “Think about it. You’re saying, ‘Today is my birthday, and there’s a reaping. Last year on my birthday, there was also a reaping. So every year, there will be a reaping on my birthday.’ But you have no way of knowing that. I mean, the reaping didn’t even exist until fifty years ago. Give me one good reason why it should keep happening just because it’s your birthday.” Her argument is logical and compelling. She deconstructs the narrator’s assumption, highlighting the arbitrary nature of the ‘reaping’ and its relatively recent origin.
Intelligence and Understanding
The narrator’s internal monologue reveals a sense of inadequacy: “For a girl who’s quiet in public, she sure can talk up a storm in private. Sometimes, she’s hard to keep up with. Lenore Dove is always patient when she explains stuff, not superior, but maybe she’s just too smart for me.” This highlights Lenore’s intellectual prowess and her ability to articulate complex ideas. The narrator acknowledges her superior understanding, but also appreciates her patience and lack of condescension.
The Power of the Capitol
Despite Lenore’s compelling arguments, the narrator remains skeptical: “Because while it’s a fine idea, thinking about a world with no reaping, I don’t really see it happening. The Capitol has all the power and that’s that.” This underscores the power dynamics at play. The ‘reaping’ is not simply a tradition, but a tool of control wielded by the Capitol. The narrator’s resignation reflects a sense of powerlessness in the face of this overwhelming force.
Lost in Thought
The excerpt concludes with the narrator’s confusion: “I didn’t say it was just because it was my birthday. I said —” What did I say? I can’t even remember now. “Sorry, you’ve lost me.” This ending leaves the reader pondering the impact of Lenore’s words. While the narrator may not be immediately convinced, the seed of doubt has been planted. The conversation has opened a space for questioning the established order and imagining a different future.
In conclusion, this excerpt masterfully explores the tension between acceptance and resistance, tradition and change. It prompts us to consider the power of perspective and the importance of challenging the narratives that shape our world.
Buy full ebook for only $15: https://www.lulu.com/shop/suzanne-collins/sunrise-on-the-reaping-a-hunger-games-novel-the-hunger-games/ebook/product-e7496ww.html?page=1&pageSize=4