Sunrise on the Reaping (A Hunger Games Novel) (The Hunger Games)
Page 173 Review
Unveiling Secrets: A Commentary on Plutarch’s Nepenthe
This excerpt from the ebook plunges us deeper into a world of secrets and hidden meanings, expertly crafted through dialogue and subtle symbolism. The scene opens with a seemingly innocuous offer, but quickly escalates into a tense exchange, fueled by curiosity and veiled challenges. Let’s dissect this captivating moment:
The Illusion of Choice
The initial setup is deceptively simple. “The top splits in two and a tray full of sparkling bottles rises in its place. Plutarch pours himself a glass of amber liquid. ‘Can I offer you something?’” This sets the stage for a seemingly cordial interaction. However, the protagonist’s immediate rejection, “‘I don’t drink,’” hints at a deeper reluctance to engage on Plutarch’s terms. This refusal isn’t merely about abstinence; it’s about maintaining control and shielding oneself from potential manipulation.
Bootlegger’s Curiosity: A Glimpse into the Protagonist’s World
The protagonist’s professional background as a bootlegger immediately colors their reaction to Plutarch’s bar. “Professional curiosity wins out, though — I’m a bootlegger, after all — and I cross to examine the booze.” This line serves as a crucial reminder of their identity and expertise. The detailed description of the various liquors, “What we call white liquor’s as clear as water, but his bar boasts every color of the rainbow. I don’t know if these have been dyed or aged or mixed with other things, like herbs. It’s all white liquor, only dressed up. The bottles have little silver nameplates on chains. Vodka. Rye. Cognac,” not only establishes Plutarch’s wealth and sophistication but also foreshadows the underlying deception and superficiality prevalent in their world.
The Significance of Nepenthe
The introduction of Nepenthe marks a turning point in the narrative. “Then I spy a name I recognize, even though I’ve never seen the stuff. I lift the bottle and let the light dance off its rosy depths. ‘It’s called nepenthe,’ says Plutarch. ‘You probably haven’t heard of it.’” Plutarch’s condescending tone, “You probably haven’t heard of it,” is a deliberate attempt to assert dominance and underestimate the protagonist’s knowledge. This arrogance, however, backfires spectacularly.
Challenging Assumptions: A Literary Revelation
The protagonist’s unexpected retort reveals a hidden depth and challenges Plutarch’s carefully constructed facade. “You’d be wrong there, Plutarch. Not only have I heard of it, I know it from the poem that gave my love her name. I’m tired of being patronized, so I decide to put him in his place. ‘You mean, like “Quaff, oh quaff this kind nepenthe . . .”?’” This is a pivotal moment. The reference to Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Raven” not only showcases the protagonist’s intelligence but also introduces a layer of romanticism and melancholy. Nepenthe, as a mythical drug meant to alleviate sorrow, resonates deeply with the theme of loss and the protagonist’s personal history.
Shared Knowledge, Unexpected Connection
Plutarch’s completion of the line, “‘. . . and forget this lost Lenore!’” is equally surprising and unsettling. “Now I’m surprised, and a little unsettled. I guess, with all these books, her poem could be here. But for him not only to have read it, but memorized…” This shared knowledge creates a fragile connection between the two characters, suggesting a deeper understanding that transcends their initial antagonism. It raises questions about Plutarch’s motives and his true identity. Why is he so familiar with the poem? What does he know about the protagonist’s “lost Lenore”?
Concluding Thoughts
This brief excerpt is a masterclass in subtle storytelling. The author skillfully uses dialogue, symbolism, and literary references to create a complex and engaging narrative. The tension between the protagonist and Plutarch is palpable, and the introduction of Nepenthe and the shared knowledge of Poe’s poem adds layers of intrigue and mystery. The scene leaves the reader eager to unravel the secrets that lie beneath the surface and discover the true nature of the connection between these two enigmatic characters.
Buy full ebook for only $15: https://www.lulu.com/shop/suzanne-collins/sunrise-on-the-reaping-a-hunger-games-novel-the-hunger-games/ebook/product-e7496ww.html?page=1&pageSize=4